1,133 is not just a number


Kenyan court dismisses most of the case against police for involvement in post-election violence

6 October 2020 - 19:10

By Susan Kendi
Kenya’s High Court has dismissed the bulk of a case in which petitioners alleged the government failed to protect them from police shootings during the violence that erupted after the December 2007 presidential election.
Judge Fred Ochieng determined that 12 out of the 15 petitioners who had filed a case before him at the High Court in Kisumu had failed to prove their case. He said they had failed to provide evidence to show police were involved in unlawful shootings or had shot them during the violence that shook Kenya between December 2007 and February 2008.
In his July 27 judgment, Judge Ochieng said he reached this conclusion, “because this is not a case in which all the Petitioners were together at one particular place, when the matters complained of took place. If the circumstances in which the incident took place were same for the Petitioners, the findings on the issue of liability would apply in uniform manner, for all the Petitioners”.
“But because the circumstances were different for each Petitioner, the Court was obliged to make specific findings based upon the evidence tendered by each Petitioner. Therefore, for all petitioners who tendered no evidence at the trial, I find that their respective claims have no factual foundation: the same are thus dismissed,” said Judge Ochieng.
The lawyer for the petitioners, Mbugua Mureithi, told Journalists for Justice he only got to know about the July 27 judgement in September.
“The first time for us to participate in the petition [since] last year, was in September. I informed the court that all these things have been happening behind our back … we have seen the judgement… we will make an application to seek leave for us to file a notice of appeal out of time,” said Mureithi.
The petitioners are 13 individuals and two civil society organisations: Citizens against Violence and the Independent Medico-Legal Unit. They first filed their petition in February 2013 in Nairobi. The case was later moved to the High Court in Kisumu. Among the things the petitioners were seeking were court orders to compel the government to effectively investigate unlawful police shootings during the post-election violence that occurred between December 2007 and February 2008.
This violence erupted after Mwai Kibaki was declared the winner of the presidential election that was held on December 27, 2007. The Commission of Inquiry into Post-Election Violence said in its report released in October 2008, that 1,133 people died in the violence out which 405 deaths were caused by gunshots wounds from police shootings.
The three petitioners Judge Ochieng found had been harmed by the actions of the police are Alice Atieno Ochieng, Hudson Bob Libabu and Tobias Wanga Odhiambo. The judge determined Odhiambo provided enough evidence to prove that it was the police that shot him.
“The police action was unlawful and brutal. It violated the 12th petitioner’s right to security of the person,” the judge said, referring to Odhiambo. He is number 12 on the list of petitioners. Judge Ochieng found that the police were responsible for failing to investigate and prosecute the perpetrator of the unlawful shooting of Odhiambo.
The Inspector General of Police is one of the respondents to the petition. The other respondents are the Attorney General, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Independent Policing Oversight Authority.
In his summary of Odhiambo’s testimony, Judge Ochieng said Odhiambo was shot while crossing the road in the company of three other people. He sustained a gunshot wound on the lower part of his right leg. Four police officers armed with rifles appeared and accused one of their colleagues of injuring Odhiambo without any justification.
The judge said Odhiambo testified that one of the officers cut a piece of his shirt sleeve and tied it on his leg to stop the bleeding and they rushed him to hospital where he was admitted until February 2008. He was then transferred to Tenwek Mission Hospital, where his right leg was amputated below the knee because it was so badly infected and it could not be saved.
The other two petitioners Judge Ochieng found the government liable for the harm they suffered are Alice Atieno Ochieng and Hudson Bob Libabu.
In his summary of the testimony of Alice Atieno Ochieng, the judge said she was shot in Kisumu and produced a Kenya Police medical report form (P3 form) showing that she had reported the incident to the Kondele police station on May 19, 2008. The judge said she could not identify the person who shot her and hence failed to prove that it was a police officer who shot her. He said that Alice Atieno Ochieng testified that her landlord, Eliud Otieno, witnessed the shooting and told her it was a police officer who shot her. Judge Ochieng said Otieno did not testify and Alice Atieno Ochieng’s account could not be corroborated.
Judge Ochieng said that Hudson Bob Libabu testified that he reported the shooting of his daughter, Barbara Sereta Lumwaji, at the Central police station in Kisumu. The judge said when Libabu reported his daughter’s killing he was informed the police had already opened an inquest into her death.
The judge found that the Attorney General and the Inspector General of Police violated Alice Atieno Ochieng’s and Hudson Bob Libabu’s right “to information and effective remedy”.

Share your thoughts

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.


quais os perigos de tomar viagra <a href="https://tvigrast.com/ ">viagra to get high</a>
quanto tempo fica o efeito do viagra <a href="https://ivigraoj.com/ ">viagra tabletten bilder</a>
can i take panadol with viagra <a href="https://dvigrarf.com/ ">pastiglie viagra</a>
dissertation coaching services <a href="https://dissertationony.com/ ">write dissertation</a>
research paper thesis <a href="https://thesistga.com/ ">help with a thesis statement</a>
thesis literature review <a href="https://thesistga.com/ ">thesis in writing</a>
prilosec samples <a href="https://prilosecomeprazolehu.com/">omeprazole coupon</a> can you take prilosec while pregnant <a href=https://prilosecomeprazolehu.com/>omeprazole diarrhea</a> ’
lexapro and alcohol side effects <a href="https://lexaproescitalopramsh.com/">lexapro starting dose</a> lexapro weight loss reviews <a href=https://lexaproescitalopramsh.com/>what is escitalopram for</a> ’
side effects to zoloft <a href="https://zoloftsertralinest.com/">sertraline weight loss</a> what is the generic name for zoloft <a href=https://zoloftsertralinest.com/>zoloft side effects first week</a> ’
benefits of cymbalta <a href="https://cymbaltaduloxetinetg.com/">withdrawal symptoms from cymbalta</a> duloxetine high <a href=https://cymbaltaduloxetinetg.com/>cymbalta drug interactions</a> ’
best time of day to take hydrochlorothiazide <a href="https://lisinoprilhydrochlorothiazidenh.com/">can lisinopril cause diarrhea</a> lisinopril hctz 20 25mg tab <a href=https://lisinoprilhydrochlorothiazidenh.com/>other names for hydrochlorothiazide</a> ’
define atorvastatin <a href="https://lipitoratorvastatinfg.com/">atorvastatin generic name</a> lipitor grapefruit <a href=https://lipitoratorvastatinfg.com/>п»їlipitor</a> ’
allergic reaction to lisinopril <a href="https://lisinoprilhydrochlorothiazidenh.com/">valsartan hydrochlorothiazide 160 12.5</a> hydrochlorothiazide ingredients <a href=https://lisinoprilhydrochlorothiazidenh.com/>lithium and hydrochlorothiazide</a> ’
mex rx cialis <a href="https://regcialist.com/">can i take cialis with daxpoteine</a> cialis with dapoxetine australia overnight delivery <a href=https://regcialist.com/>dapoxetine and cialis</a> ’
online pharmacy ezzz viagra <a href="https://onviamen.com/">cheapest viagra online</a> viagra super active <a href=https://onviamen.com/>is viagra covered by health insurance</a> ’
reputable canadian pharmacy <a href="https://storpharmon.com/">are canadian pharmacy drugs safe</a> is canadian pharmacy safe <a href=https://storpharmon.com/>canada world pharmacy</a> ’
generic viagra name <a href="https://viaedpik.com/">poppers and viagra</a> is viagra bad for you <a href=https://viaedpik.com/>viagra and high blood pressure</a> ’
brand cialis for sale <a href="https://regcialist.com/">i want to buy cialis in australia</a> cheapest cialis 5mg <a href=https://regcialist.com/>generic cialis</a> ’
Gyne-Lotrimin <a href="https://pharmpharms.com/">pharmacy online cheap</a> Clomid <a href=https://pharmpharms.com/>prescription drug price comparison</a> ’
womens viagra <a href="https://viagrviagrs.com/">viagra dose</a> women viagra <a href=https://viagrviagrs.com/>generic viagra cheap</a> ’
topical rx pharmacy tallahassee fl <a href="https://inpharmxx.com/">mexican border pharmacies</a> canadian pharmacy in canada <a href=https://inpharmxx.com/>best canadian prescription prices</a> ’
cialis forms <a href="https://opencialicli.com/">cialis com</a> brand cialis on line <a href=https://opencialicli.com/>cialis online without perscription</a> ’
canadian pharmacy prices <a href="https://storpharmon.com/">online order medicine</a> canada discount drug <a href=https://storpharmon.com/>discount prescription drugs</a> ’
snort viagra <a href="https://onviamen.com/">viagra without a prescription</a> can you get viagra over the counter <a href=https://onviamen.com/>teva generic viagra cost</a> ’
cialis wallmart <a href="https://regcialist.com/">cialis from safeway</a> cialis in melbourne australia <a href=https://regcialist.com/>cialis 20 mg</a> ’
generic viagra us <a href="http://vigedon.com/ ">online pharmacy viagra cheap </a> viagra in europe
where can i get cialis overnite <a href="http://llecialisjaw.com/ ">how to order cialis </a> cialis 20mg sell
viagra knock offs <a href="http://viagriyvik.com/ ">http://viagriyvik.com/ </a> health care products,viagra toronto
trial coupon for cialis <a href="https://jecialisbn.com/ ">cialis 0 25</a> acquistare cialis senza prescrizione
payday loan anaheim ca <a href="http://ascashapply.com/ ">sunday funding payday loans</a> merchant cash advance apr calculator
cialis e gravidanza <a href="http://ljcialishe.com/ ">cialis e ansiolitici</a> cialis per problemi psicologici
most reliable canadian pharmacies <a href="http://lightvigra.com/ ">how to talk to a doctor about viagra</a> 365 pills viagra
quick cash loans brisbane <a href="http://rirocash.com/ ">internet cash advances</a> allied cash advance california llc
viagra/canada <a href="http://hopeviagrin.com/ ">ed drugs</a> viagra paypal to australia
buy cialis in australia <a href="http://cialisvja.com/ ">cialis cheap</a> generic cialis india
pain meds online without doctor prescription <a href="https://ssviagriia.com/ ">viagra uk</a> canadian family pharmacy
shoppers drug mart pharmacy <a href="http://happyrxpharmacy21.com/ ">canadian pharmacy no prescription</a> canadian pharmacy online
ordering prescriptions from canada legally <a href="http://online21rxon.com/ ">indian pharmacy</a> canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
viagra ustralia <a href="http://llviabest.com/#">viagrapatent expiration date</a> generic viagra http://llviabest.com/ - viagra australia prescription ’
buy viagra online ireland <a href="http://genqpviag.com/#">least expensive viagra</a> viagra cialis trial pack http://genqpviag.com/ - viagra 100mg no prescription ’
buy viagra online ireland <a href="http://genqpviag.com/#">least expensive viagra</a> viagra cialis trial pack http://genqpviag.com/ - viagra 100mg no prescription ’
<a href=http://smartbuying.biz/go.php?sid=26&tds-key=Pyridium><img src="http://boys-here.com/promo/es/wfulo219n.jpg"></a> <a href=http://smartbuying.biz/go.php?sid=26&tds-key=Pyridium><u><b>Ordenar Pyridium 200 mg Barato En Línea</b></u></a> <a href=http://smartbuying.biz/go.php?sid=26&tds-key=Pyridium><u> ⇒ ENTRE AQUí ⇐ </u></a> donde comprar pyridium ou fenazopiridina http://deleoww.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=buyranitidine300mgonlinesafely.soup.io pyridium compra venta comprar pyridium en pamplona pyridium 200mg como comprar <i>comprar pyridium en el salvador</i> pyridium phenazopyridine 200 mg precio donde puedo comprar pyridium por internet Argentina puedo comprar fenazopiridina en la farmacia sin receta medica http://www.viscardischool.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=de.gravatar.com/anfraroutdalrore sitios de confianza para comprar pyridium 200mg comprar phenazopyridine 200 mg masticable España comprar pyridium 200mg necesito receta. donde comprar pyridium para hombres, comprar pyridium en new york. comprar pyridium online de forma segura; pyridium en andorra sin receta. donde comprar pyridium en miami http://illicojeu.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=gravatar.com/comprartantrix farmacias en madrid para comprar pyridium sin receta pyridium venta libre capital federal: comprar pyridium 200 mg recomendado. pyridium se vende sin receta en mexico comprar pyridium 200 mg morelia michoacan donde comprar pyridium para mujeres en peru: donde comprar pyridium 200 mg. pyridium 200mg mexico venta. phenazopyridine con receta o sin receta República de Chile <u>pyridium chile precio</u> pyridium es de venta libre. donde puedo comprar pyridium de forma segura. pyridium generico 200mg precio; comprar pyridium sandia; pyridium 200mg venta en chile. comprar pyridium 200mg consta. donde puedo comprar pyridium para mujeres en argentina. pyridium sin receta mexico. el pyridium se vende sin receta en ecuador.comprar pyridium generico en barcelona comprar pyridium por contrareembolso República de Chile <b>comprar pyridium 200mg natural en madrid</b> precio de pyridium phenazopyridine comprar pyridium mastercard <i>donde puedo comprar pyridium sin receta mexico</i> comprar pyridium españa barcelona comprar pyridium 200 mg por internet venta República del Perú pyridium 200 mg sin receta medica México <u></u> donde comprar pyridium femenino en buenos aires pyridium 200mg internet comprar. es necesaria receta para comprar pyridium en andorra, comprar pyridium normon 200 mg. donde comprar pyridium en la plata. pyridium 200mg comprar andorra. comprar pyridium en farmacia barcelona. pyridium 200 mg venta bajo receta archivada, se puede comprar pyridium generico en farmacias. pyridium 200mg cual comprar, comprar pyridium contrareembolso espana. comprar pyridium 200mg por internet o en la farmacia, comprar pyridium hombres. comprar pyridium online de forma segura, pyridium precio costa rica; pyridium 200mg oral jelly comprar. donde comprar pyridium en estados unidos comprar fenazopiridina 200mg sin receta contrareembolso <u>pyridium sin receta en farmacias</u> <b>comprar pyridium 200mg por internet en españa</b> <i>pyridium 200mg precio</i> comprar pyridium soft tabs pyridium 200 mg venta montevideo <u>comprar pyridium en argentina sin receta</u> <b>donde comprar pyridium sin receta en san isidro</b> comprar pyridium sin receta valencia comprar pyridium 200mg magnus comprar generico de pyridium contrareembolso <i></i> http://saffe.net/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=gravatar.com/inderallanax comprar pyridium oral jelly pyridium 200 mg df venta. se puede comprar pyridium sin receta en farmacia, pyridium generico precio peru. comprar pyridium 200 mg mundo http://paralleltowers.net/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=gravatar.com/glibenclamidanv comprar pyridium farmacia similares